Manlove-related opinion poll.

[Foxy Brown]

The age old question: Who's gayer? The pitcher or the catcher?

Point: The catcher is a man getting penetrated by another man, which is generally seen as being submissive.

Counterpoint: While the catcher can be a passive participant, the pitcher must be able to get sexually excited enough to maintain an erection at the thought of putting that erection into another man.

Discuss.

[shadowstar]

I'd say the catcher.

Just because the first thought in my head is that the pitcher could be pretending he's just doing a girl 

[Pharadox]

The point and counterpoint do not seem to allow for the possibility that one or both are bisexual, which seems to affect the quality of gayness in this context.

But overall, my first instinct was to say catcher.