Damn TommyVD, I was JUST writing a long rant about the EXACT SAME POINT. (On my computer, to myself, don't know where I would post it if I ever will.) Yes. You said it perfectly. They are so quick to give advice, but who are they to give advice, truly? Are these really the people we want to have giving advice to new members? People who got booted from the group for breaking idol rules? People who get caught smoking, plagiarizing, cheating on their husbands? It's ridiculous. The new members have a much better rolemodel right now in someone like Sayumi who is professional, ambitious, kind, and knows how to handle her private life (= out of the spotlight). I also like Rika and Yossi as rolemodels, and there are others, but I almost feel that the loudest advice givers are the worst advice givers.