JPHiP Forum

HiP Nation => Classic Threads => Classic H!P => Topic started by: shirenuファクトリー on December 19, 2008, 02:38:29 PM

Title: Best H!P Concert DVD of 2008?
Post by: shirenuファクトリー on December 19, 2008, 02:38:29 PM
~If I missed something, please comment ASAP~


Which concerts did you enjoy the most? CAST YOUR VOTE! :3
Title: Re: Best H!P Concert DVD of 2008?
Post by: emifebruary on December 19, 2008, 03:01:02 PM
For me :

Morning Musume 2008 Spring ~Single Daizenshuu~ cause I've seen it Live  :)
Title: Re: Best H!P Concert DVD of 2008?
Post by: Stryfe on December 19, 2008, 03:02:10 PM
Hey I think I even watched a few, or at least fast forwarded! One had all that Aichan ownage...

(http://img148.imageshack.us/img148/9066/aimoonlight2gq0.jpg)


And the other had this...

(http://img152.imageshack.us/img152/1959/snapshot20081218151506brd5.jpg)(http://img152.imageshack.us/img152/5492/snapshot20081218151522haz1.jpg)


Yeah! I'll vote for those, right after I figure out their names...
Title: Re: Best H!P Concert DVD of 2008?
Post by: shirenuファクトリー on December 19, 2008, 03:23:01 PM
Sorry sorry I'd forgotten Wonderful Hearts Summer!! It's been added now...

I voted:
Morning Musume 2008 Spring ~Single Daizenshuu~: This was just an awesome concert. DUHH all their singles!! :heart:

H!P Shinjin Kouen Sept. "Shiba Kouen STEP": Because of the great setlist and because it really was entertaining :D

Hello! Project 2008 Summer Wonderful Hearts Kouen: Because I quite like the current H!P, it had some cool perfs, and was crowned by the evil Ame no furanai performance T_T :heart:

If I had one more vote, I would vote Berryz & C-ute 2008 Spring Berryz Kamen vs Cutie Ranger. :D
Title: Re: Best H!P Concert DVD of 2008?
Post by: SomethingWild on December 19, 2008, 03:33:47 PM

 Morning Musume 2008 Spring ~Single Daizenshuu~
 Viyuden 2008 Summer "BiyuuDensetsu"
 Hello! Project 2008 Summer Wonderful Hearts Kouen

I probably watched/enjoyed these the most. I was about to give up on MM after the bonkyu tour, but they redeemed themselves with the all singles tour.

Title: Re: Best H!P Concert DVD of 2008?
Post by: Ayabie on December 19, 2008, 03:35:59 PM
I haven't even watched half of those, but...

Berryz & C-ute 2008 Spring Berryz Kamen vs Cutie Ranger
Berryz Kobo - 2008 Fall ~Berikore!~
H!P Shinjin Kouen Sept. "Shiba Kouen STEP"

Shiba Kouen is the big favorite, though.
Title: Re: Best H!P Concert DVD of 2008?
Post by: mini*wheat on December 19, 2008, 05:36:34 PM
Berryz & C-ute 2008 Spring Berryz Kamen vs Cutie Ranger
Morning Musume 2008 Spring ~Single Daizenshuu~
H!P Shinjin Kouen Sept. "Shiba Kouen STEP" <-- I've been falling in love with the eggs and their concerts.  :heart: :heart: :heart:
Title: Re: Best H!P Concert DVD of 2008?
Post by: Fenrir on December 19, 2008, 05:44:46 PM
MM - Bonkyu Bonkyu! Just cuz I saw that live.
I liked MM - Single Daizenshuu better, but alas, I didn't go see that one live. I wonder why I didn't... Must have been busy.
Title: Re: Best H!P Concert DVD of 2008?
Post by: genericpaperdoll on December 19, 2008, 07:00:55 PM
Morning Musume 2008 Spring ~Single Daizenshuu~
H!P Shinjin Kouen Sept. "Shiba Kouen STEP" (we need more Egg concerts on dvd)

Ongaku Gatas 2008 Spring ~Mizaru Iwazaru GOODSAL!~ too, but I missed it before :doh:
(way to fail...that was like my favorite..)
Title: Re: Best H!P Concert DVD of 2008?
Post by: Rina the Robot on December 19, 2008, 07:18:59 PM
Berryz & C-ute 2008 Spring Berryz Kamen vs Cutie Ranger
Morning Musume 2008 Spring ~Single Daizenshuu~
C-ute Cutie Circuit 2008 ~LOVE Escalation!~

The kids have really been coming into their own and these concerts sealed the deal for me.
Title: Re: Best H!P Concert DVD of 2008?
Post by: Naomi on December 19, 2008, 08:14:16 PM
Hello! Project 2008 Winter (Though I actually prefer Elder Club's concert. ;D)
Ongaku Gatas 2008 Spring
C-ute Cutie Circuit 2008

Edit
Aw crap. I forgot about the Berryz/C-ute concert... I'd probably put that instead of the Cutie Circuit or OG concert...
Title: Re: Best H!P Concert DVD of 2008?
Post by: shurastriker on December 19, 2008, 08:53:27 PM
- morning musume all singles
- Berryz vs C-ute
- WH kouen? is that the one with the girls in tennis uniforms?
Title: Re: Best H!P Concert DVD of 2008?
Post by: yumestarlet on December 19, 2008, 09:18:30 PM
Berryz & C-ute 2008 Spring Berryz Kamen vs Cutie Ranger
Morning Musume 2008 Spring ~Single Daizenshuu~

^ These two for SURE.

The Berryz & C-ute concert was AMAZING. I don't ever get bored watching that concert.
And the Morning Musume Single concert was just EPIC. With Ai in Mr. Moonlight... yeah, that one can't be beat.

The third one I voted for was the Bonkyu! BOMB concert, because I enjoyed that one too. :)
Title: Re: Best H!P Concert DVD of 2008?
Post by: Brat-san on December 19, 2008, 09:31:38 PM
Kamen vs. Ranger
Wonderful Hearts

First one pretty much was amazing compared to our expectations, and awesome.  Second I loved the shuffling. :3
Title: Re: Best H!P Concert DVD of 2008?
Post by: Wonderboy on December 19, 2008, 10:19:09 PM
Not easy at all...

Well : BerryZ Kamen vs °C-utie Rangers.
Title: Re: Best H!P Concert DVD of 2008?
Post by: 楊枝君 on December 20, 2008, 01:40:36 AM
I voted for Berryz vs °C-ute, September Shinjin Kouen and Wonderful Hearts Kouen. I fail epically at remembering names, so that's the best I could come up with without looking at the list while typing this XD;;;
Title: Re: Best H!P Concert DVD of 2008?
Post by: Nouciel on December 20, 2008, 04:52:42 AM
C-ute Cutie Circuit 2008 ~LOVE Escalation!~
Berryz & C-ute 2008 Spring Berryz Kamen vs Cutie Ranger. The setlist looked disappointing at first but I don't have to skip any song there. Favourite concert of this year.
Morning Musume 2008 Spring ~Single Daizenshuu~
Title: Re: Best H!P Concert DVD of 2008?
Post by: JFC on December 20, 2008, 07:33:04 PM
Morning Musume 2008 Spring ~Single Daizenshuu~ 
Viyuden 2008 Summer "BiyuuDensetsu"
Matsuura Aya 2008 Spring "AYA The Witch"

:yep:
Title: Re: Best H!P Concert DVD of 2008?
Post by: redux on December 20, 2008, 08:56:15 PM
Only one vote needed: Morning Musume 2007 Fall ~Bonkyu! Bonkyu! BOMB~
Title: Re: Best H!P Concert DVD of 2008?
Post by: renzoku on December 21, 2008, 03:31:59 AM
Morning Musume 2008 Spring ~Single Daizenshuu~ FTW
Title: Re: Best H!P Concert DVD of 2008?
Post by: daigong on December 27, 2008, 05:58:03 AM
Gotta go with Viyuden 2008 Summer "BiyuuDensetsu" (http://forum.jphip.com/index.php?topic=17725.0)

(http://img126.imageshack.us/img126/127/rikarp9.jpg)

Last concerts really hit hard...HARD  :banghead: :thumbdown:
Title: Re: Best H!P Concert DVD of 2008?
Post by: tenkei on December 27, 2008, 06:08:18 AM
no FC concert DVDs? (Buono's was good >.>)

voted for Morning Musume 2008 Spring ~Single Daizenshuu~ cus it was quite awesome
Title: Re: Best H!P Concert DVD of 2008?
Post by: shadowstar on December 27, 2008, 09:48:29 AM
1. Morning Musume 2008 Spring ~Single Daizenshuu~  :heart:
2. Morning Musume 2007 Fall ~Bonkyu! Bonkyu! BOMB~
3. Hello!Project 2008 Summer Wonderful Hearts Kouen
Title: Re: Best H!P Concert DVD of 2008?
Post by: ichijoujirena on January 17, 2009, 10:41:44 PM
1. Berryz & C-ute 2008 Spring Berryz Kamen vs Cutie Ranger  :muffin:
2. C-ute 2008 Summer ~Wasuretakunai natsu~
3. Morning Musume 2008 Spring ~Single Daizenshuu~
Title: Re: Best H!P Concert DVD of 2008?
Post by: freakn_emo on October 30, 2009, 10:43:40 PM
for me gatas' concert was the best compare to all the rest even biyuden's
Title: Re: Best H!P Concert DVD of 2008?
Post by: Rayle on November 01, 2009, 05:55:25 PM
I voted BerryzVsC-ute, All-Singles, and H!P Summer. Berikore was really fighting H!P Summer for that spot, though.

I went for H!P Summer because my love for Berikore stemmed more from the songlist and the performers than the actual concert production. I'm also a sucker for the H!P mix and match subunits too, and here they worked quite well. High-King! For more than one number! :w00t: Airi-Linlin-OgaSaki!  :mon angel: The summer theme was also more prevalent here than in the winter concerts, so the concert felt more unified, rather than "Our new singles! Some random shuffles! Special Generation and LoveMachine/RR21/ThePeace!". The costumes for the most part were pretty good, and of course the Ame finale was epic.(And the song hadn't been BEATEN TO DEATH YET.)

BerryzVsC-ute not only had a great songlist, but the subunit rosters were also quite strong, and I don't think there was really a "Make some great subunits(that made sense) and group the leftovers for a number" situation that seems to pop up in other concerts. The costumes were also decent, and the fact that the concert theme was something brought up again and again was very refreshing. More often than not the H!P concert names seem to be just tags, but here it was the driving force.

All-Singles had A LOT of production to match its epic premise. The medleys were mostly well-put together, and the solo distributions mostly made sense. The costumes were pretty good, too. And just the overall effort put into the concert on every front was so much that I couldn't not vote for it. I think it also set the benchmark for 9-nin MM 2.0. The extra work needed to cram 35+ songs into one concert really helped the lineup bond. The difference in the girls between BKBKB and Resonant Live is ridiculously apparent, and a completely different MM than in Sexy 8 Beat. And it seems lots of the good concepts from All-Singles were further explored in Resonant Live and P9D, extremely strong concerts. The medleys with changed arrangements, the generation-based MCs, etc. I find that production values for MM in general rose after this, with SYO and P9D having so many bonus treats.(They seem to be fading again, however.)