JPHiP Forum
The PIEHOLE => H!P Crapola => Topic started by: bluewind78 on November 29, 2016, 02:59:02 PM
-
With all the mania of new generations for even the newer groups like TF, would you want JUICE=JUICE to be a generational unit too?!
-
NO :banghead:
-
But you know what happens to h!p units that don't have generational grads & additions? Berryz & C-ute get disbanded.
So I'm on the fence about this :wth
-
I prefer they let J=J to remain as they are,
unless any of the current five graduated.
(http://picroda.jphip.com/hp/jphip37917.jpg)
-
Well, I'm of the opinion they have the potential to grow and go on to bigger things/goals if they remain as the current 5-nin. J=J looks like a group that could evolve and forge a legacy (their own path) through a shared history much like C-ute and Berryz once were. Adding a new member that did not go thru the same shared experience these 5-nin had together kinda disturb the dynamic. These 5-nin went through the same hard times, the gruelling 225 concert schedules before realizing a shared dream. Its going to be very difficult for any new girl, however good she is, to measure up to the senior members, especially in terms of experience.
-
We need a stable group like J=J :lol: I kind of perceive them as doing their own thing and not needing a newer gen to 'keep things going'
But you know what happens to h!p units that don't have generational grads & additions? Berryz & C-ute get disbanded.
So I'm on the fence about this :wth
Yeah they disband, AFTER LIKE 10+ YEARS :lol: At some point it's better to disband than force the name to continue with new people if that wasn't always the plan. Even S/mileage changed their name after the group changed so much.
And the good thing about H!P is that the songs will never die, because everyone performs each others' songs :3
-
They should add Ayano Kawamura to the group just so they could mess with people. Her fruit would be blueberry.
-
Yeah, I'm on the no train. I think a stable group in something as unstable as the idol world is a GREAT thing (especially after losing Berryz and C-ute). It makes them stand out and by now, they've been at this long enough, it'd feel weird to add a 2nd gen.
-
Maybe I should've added a 3rd option:
Option C: Only if Aina Otsuka rejoins the group. :twisted:
Kinda makes me think about it though...what would it have been like for their journey to Budokan had Tsukapon remained with the group.
-
Jicchan gives the translations of some opinions (back in 2014 though):
https://jicchan.wordpress.com/2014/04/07/would-you-guys-approve-of-new-members-being-added-to-juicejuice/