Author Topic: The Ran! ki!! ng!!! Thread (Anything goes edition) (Read 39787 times)

Special Needs Tricycle · « **Reply #20 on:** February 11, 2010, 03:56:51 AM »

I love sorters!

1   Michelle Miki
2   Sakai Hitomi
3   Hashimoto Kaede
4   Koizumi Rumi
5   Morita Suzuka
6   Kikuchi Ami
7   Yazawa Erika
8   Katou Sayaka
9   Tachibana Yurika
10   Yokoyama Rurika
11   Endou Mai
12   Tonooka Erika
13   Kawamura Yui
14   Asahi Nao
15   Eto Maria
16   Nagano Serina
17   Takiguchi Mira
18   Ookawa Ai
19   Miyake Hitomi
20   Phongchi
21   Kobayashi Maia

Ayabie · « **Reply #21 on:** February 11, 2010, 10:18:48 AM »

This looks about right to me.

1 Endou Mai
2 Koizumi Rumi
3 Morita Suzuka
4 Asahi Nao
5 Ookawa Ai
6 Fonchi
7 Hashimoto Kaede
8 Yazawa Erika
9 Kikuchi Ami
10 Katou Sayaka
11 Eto Maria
12 Sakai Hitomi
--- Takiguchi Mira
14 Tonooka Erica
--- Michelle Miki
--- Yokoyama Rurika
--- Miyake Hitomi
18 Kawamura Yui
19 Tachibana Yurika
--- Nagano Serina
21 Kobayashi Maia

Gihren · « **Reply #22 on:** February 11, 2010, 11:04:17 AM »

Lol Idoling sorter is pretty handy, i got so much ties cause im so indecisive i guess.
I've followed Idoling since 1st gen but was never a fan till i saw them doing their mini live in Odaiba Gasshuukoku (was there to check out the Gundam) lol. Can't get enough of Ton-chan and Hii-chan.

1 Tonooka Erica
- Miyake Hitomi
3 Yokoyama Rurika
- Endou Mai
5 Ookawa Ai
- Fonchi
7 Yazawa Erika
8 Morita Suzuka
9 Sakai Hitomi
- Tachibana Yurika
- Asahi Nao
12 Katou Sayaka
--- Koizumi Rumi
14 Eto Maria
--- Hashimoto Kaede
--- Kawamura Yui
--- Nagano Serina
18 Kikuchi Ami
19 Takiguchi Mira
20 Michelle Miki
21 Kobayashi Maia

1517 · « **Reply #23 on:** February 11, 2010, 12:05:41 PM »

just one try, no draw click, damn...AsaHi-chan was turned up-side down and Maia at 15.

Blue_Sweater · « **Reply #24 on:** February 11, 2010, 04:22:58 PM »

Sorter is cool. Thanks for the link. Here is my full list:

1   Katou Sayaka
2   Koizumi Rumi
3   Endou Mai
4   Ookawa Ai
5   Tonooka Erica
5   Yazawa Erika
7   Asahi Nao
8   Tachibana Yurika
9   Eto Maria
10   Morita Suzuka
10   Kikuchi Ami
10   Yokoyama Rurika
13   Nagano Serina
13   Miyake Hitomi
15   Kawamura Yui
15   Takiguchi Mira
17   Fonchi
17   Hashimoto Kaede
17   Sakai Hitomi
20   Michelle Miki
21   Kobayashi Maia

Blue_Sweater · « **Reply #25 on:** February 11, 2010, 04:55:40 PM »

Got a little bored so decided to do some analysis based on the 6 ranked results posted on this thread.

Rank   Name     Points     Average rank   Standard deviation
1   Endou Mai     28     4.7     3.7
2   Koizumi Rumi     32     5.3     4.2
3   Yazawa Erika     42     7.0     1.9
4   Ookawa Ai     43     7.2     5.4
6   Asahi Nao     48     8.0     4.6
6   Morita Suzuka     48     8.0     3.8
7   Tonooka Erica     49     8.2     5.0
9   Katou Sayaka     53     8.8     7.5
9   Yokoyama Rurika 53     8.8     4.4
10   Miyake Hitomi     62     10.3     7.2
12   Kikuchi Ami     70     11.7     5.1
12   Fonchi     70     11.7     6.0
13   Sakai Hitomi     71     11.8     5.6
15   Hashimoto Kaede 74     12.3     6.1
15   Tachibana Yurika 74     12.3     4.9
16   Michelle Miki     75     12.5     8.5
17   Kawamura Yui     83     13.8     4.3
18   Eto Maria     85     14.2     3.9
19   Nagano Serina     88     14.7     5.6
20   Takiguchi Mira     92     15.3     3.7
21   Kobayashi Maia     119     19.8     2.4

Some interesting observations from this:
- Endou and Koizumi own this lists (for good reason:) )
- Ookawa is surprisingly popular, ranking 4th, much higher than her 3rd gen peers. On the other hand, Takiguchi is surprisingly high in the ranking across the board (ranking 2nd last overall)
- Katou and Michelle seem to be the most 'controversial' idols, i.e. they got both very high and very low rankings (Katou got two 1's and one 21; Michelle got two top3 and two 20's).
- Yazawa on the other hand is the most consistent, ranking 5 to 10 on the 6 lists.
- Seems like 'cuteness' does not sell as Hashimoto and Nagano both come in quite lowly
- Generation-wise, 1st Gen comes out on top (9.3 avg. ranking) followed by 3rd Gen (10.6) and 2nd (12.3). Go 1st Gen!

Will add update the results if there are more lists posted...

kei_86 · « **Reply #26 on:** February 11, 2010, 05:37:32 PM »

thanks for the link to the sorters.

1   Kawamura Yui   60
2   Fonchi    57
3   Katou Sayaka   54
4   Koizumi Rumi   51
5   Takiguchi Mira   48
6   Nagano Serina   45
7   Morita Suzuka   42
8   Yazawa Erika   39
9   Eto Maria     36
10   Asahi Nao     33
11   Yurippe     30
12   Rurika     27
13   Kikuchi Ami   24
14   Sakai Hitomi   21
15   Kaede    18
16   Miyake Hitomi   15
17   Endou Mai   12
18   Ookawa Ai   9
19   Tonooka Erika   6
20   Michelle Miki   3
21   Kobayashi M. 0

Gihren · « **Reply #27 on:** February 12, 2010, 12:15:01 AM »

Thanks Blue_Sweater, its pretty interesting to check out the stats especially your little comment at the bottom

Blue_Sweater · « **Reply #28 on:** February 12, 2010, 10:46:38 AM »

No problem:) Glad you appreciate it. It was pretty fun compiling the result as well!

shirenuファクトリー · « **Reply #29 on:** February 13, 2010, 01:07:05 PM »

I tried the sorter even if I still don't really know anyone >_>

1 Kawamura Yui 60 - For some reason she seems super likeable, idk. It's a ~feeling
2 Miyake Hitomi 57 - I like princesses
3 Yazawa Erika 54 - Nuts! Hilariousss
4 Morita Suzuka 51 - She's adorable
5 Tachibana Yurika 48 - I like her smile
6 Ookawa Ai 45 - She amused me in something but I don't remember what haha
7 Hashimoto Kaede 42 - So cute
8 Nagano Serina 39 - hyper
9 Fonchi 36 - kinda weird (in a good way)
10 Endou Mai 33
11 Tonooka Erica 30 - I thought I would like her tons at first because I actually knew her from gravure before I knew she was in Idoling, but somehow she doesn't really stand out that much
12 Sakai Hitomi 27 - Didn't stand out to me at first but I liked some recent pics posted in her thread

13 Asahi Nao 24
14 Yokoyama Yurika 21
15 Katou Sayaka 18
16 Koizumi Rumi 15
17 Eto Maria 12
18 Kikuchi Ami 9
19 Michelle Miki 6
20 Takiguchi Mira 3
21 Kobayashi Maia 0

Lazypanda · « **Reply #30 on:** February 16, 2010, 06:33:38 PM »

i don't really know anything about these girls but so far the ones that got my attention the most are

1 asahi noe

2 tonooka erika

SomethingWild · « **Reply #31 on:** February 17, 2010, 03:56:56 PM »

^Excellent! My favs as well

Did a quick ranking.. made a couple mistakes because the pics didn't load fast enough

1   外岡えりか   60
2   朝日奈央   57
3   谷澤恵里香   54
4   小泉瑠美   51
5   フォンチー   48
6   小林麻衣愛   45
7   橋本楓   42
8   酒井瞳   39
9   森田涼花   36
10   遠藤舞   33
11   長野せりな   30
12   橘ゆりか   27
13   菊地亜美   24
14   大川藍   21
15   加藤沙耶香   18
16   三宅ひとみ   15
17   滝口ミラ   12
18   江渡万里彩   9
19   横山ルリカ   6
20   河村唯   3
21   ミシェル未来0

SuzukiRyo · « **Reply #32 on:** February 17, 2010, 11:45:28 PM »

1   横山ルリカ   60
2   酒井瞳   57
3   遠藤舞   54
4   小泉瑠美   51
5   フォンチー   48
6   三宅ひとみ   45
7   河村唯   42
8   外岡えりか   39
9   森田涼花   36
10   大川藍   33
11   加藤沙耶香   30
12   朝日奈央   27
13   菊地亜美   24
14   江渡万里彩   21
15   谷澤恵里香   18
16   橋本楓   15
17   滝口ミラ   12
18   長野せりな   9
19   橘ゆりか   6
20   ミシェル未来   3
21   小林麻衣愛 0

sorry for kobayashi fans, since i haven't watched any episode of her.
sakacchi & maipuru replaced Umeko and Ai.
i love how sakacchi speaks.
crushed to maipuru after watching behind the scene of 4th live.

no one can replace rurika

Ayabie · « **Reply #33 on:** June 11, 2010, 11:24:11 PM »

Time to rank the 4th generation!

1 Kurata Ruka
- Has a lot of potential as a second Kaede, even though I think she's a bit brighter.

Her best line so far has to be when she commented on Koopa being an enemy on #628. Also, give her a few more months of practice and she'll take Idoling!!!'s choreography to another level.

2 Itou Yuuna
- I've been strangely attracted to that weird aura of her's even from the audition pictures.

Hopefully we'll get to see some more ventriloquism from her, though it's too bad there's already been a Mania-Idol about it.

3 Ojima Chika
- First of all, damn she's loud.

I'm not sure what to think if her right now, but the rivalry with Ookawa is working out great for her.

4 Nomoto Manami
- She has a real Tonooka vibe going around her with her talking without a real punchline thing.

She also seems to have personal concerns regarding her weight which could be a problem if it gets put to use on the show too much.

5 Gotou Kaoru
- Out of all five so far I'd say she has the weakest personality from what we've seen so far, so there's not much to do except wait.

winner · « **Reply #34 on:** June 12, 2010, 01:43:34 AM »

Since I haven't done the vote earlier. I'll just select a fave from each gen to make a top 3 (otherwise I could go crazy balancing 3 1st gens).
1. Saya-nee (Endo I love. But Saya-nee = Idoling!!! for me)
2. Asahi Nao (She's cute, cool, funny, fashionable, and a guy?! that's the whole package right there!)
3. Ookawa Ai (she's crazy. mmm... yup)

back to 4th gen. I meant it when I said I liked the 2 crybabies.

1. Itou Yuuna (i like the weird aura too!)
2. Nomoto Manami (she does have a summer feel like Toonoka too... And a really nice smile)
3. Ojima Chika (she took on Ookawa in the ring TWICE in #625, and lived. Making her crazy x2. yup)
4. Gotou Kaoru (because Ruka just looks too young. And I think Kaoru is actually rather pretty in her own way)
5. Kurata Ruka (she's mostly been off my radar. which may be because I don't understand japanese, so I miss out on most of what they say)

kei_86 · « **Reply #35 on:** June 13, 2010, 09:03:54 PM »

My 4th gen ranking:

1. Itou Yuuna : I like the way she speaks, and her tsukkomi are real fast and sharp that its really fun. Plus she reminds me of Rumi with her sharp tongue and Ojamajo Doremi.

2. Ojima Chika : She's absolutely fun and quite weird too. She's always laughing/smiling and she looks good with that

3. Nomoto Manami : Her gorilla impersonation totally reminds me of Mira, could be a gem waiting to be polished. Looking forward to her real character soon

4. Kurata Ruka : Her dance during the 8th live was simply off the hook and something never seen before in any Idoling!!! concert. Her accent is really cute and she make such a cute pair with Kaede.

5. Gotou Kaoru : Still being very careful with the show, need to let go a bit. Only time will tell.

SuzukiRyo · « **Reply #36 on:** June 22, 2010, 07:01:13 PM »

http://www9.atwiki.jp/kusakaoru/pages/1352.html
updated including 4th generation.

N.    Name   Point
1   横山ルリカ   75 *Rurika still has special place in my heart ♥
2   遠藤舞   72 *The best singer in idol world ever
3   酒井瞳   69 *I'm falling in love with Miyazaki's dialect
4   三宅ひとみ   66 *Ojou-sama wins
5   フォンチー   63
6   倉田瑠夏   60 *I have a high hope for her to be Rurika's successor
7   朝日奈央   57 *Ahopop wins
8   河村唯   54
9   大川藍   51
10   橋本楓   48
11   小泉瑠美   45
12   加藤沙耶香   42
13   外岡えりか   39
14   長野せりな   36
15   谷澤恵里香   33
16   野元愛   30
17   菊地亜美   27 *I like her lately
18   尾島知佳   24
19   森田涼花   21
20   伊藤祐奈   18 *She has some potentials. Looking forward to it.
21   後藤郁   15
22   江渡万里彩   12
23   橘ゆりか   9
24   滝口ミラ   6
25   ミシェル未来   3 *Idol world is not her world
26   小林麻衣愛   0 *she is not even on the graduated list.

kei_86 · « **Reply #37 on:** June 23, 2010, 03:27:43 AM »

1   河村唯   75
2   小泉瑠美   72
3   江渡万里彩   69
4   加藤沙耶香   66
5   フォンチー   63
6   菊地亜美   60
7   滝口ミラ   57
8   谷澤恵里香   54
9   橋本楓   51
10   尾島知佳   48
11   大川藍   45
12   朝日奈央   42
13   森田涼花   39
14   長野せりな   36
15   橘ゆりか   33
16   遠藤舞   30
17   伊藤祐奈   27
18   酒井瞳   24
19   三宅ひとみ   21
20   横山ルリカ   18
21   野元愛   15
22   外岡えりか   12
23   後藤郁   9
24   倉田瑠夏   6
25   ミシェル未来   3
26   小林麻衣愛   0

what really surprises me is that how much Amimi has gone up in my ranking and how far down Serina went. Kaede is going up steadily as well. Yuuna could probably go up very soon too

Special Needs Tricycle · « **Reply #38 on:** June 23, 2010, 08:28:07 AM »

1   Sakai Hitomi
2   Hashimoto Kaede
3   Morita Suzuka
4   Kikuchi Ami
5   Tachibana Yurika
6   Michelle Miki
7   Yazawa Erika
8   Ookawa Ai
9   Koizumi Rumi
10   Katou Sayaka
11   Endou Mai
12   Kawamura Yui
13   Yokoyama Rurika
14   Itou Yuuna
15   Tonooka Erica
16   Kurata Ruka
17   Takiguchi Mira
18   Asahi Nao
19   Ojima Chika
20   Eto Maria
21   Nomoto Manami
22   Nagano Serina
23   Phongchi
24   Miyake Hitomi
25   Gotou Kaoru
26   Kobayashi Maia

Old favorites are falling and new ones rising. I'd like to do this again in a few months when 4th gen is fully settled in. :> I feel bad seeing them this low when they haven't had a chance to do much.

Blue_Sweater · « **Reply #39 on:** July 10, 2010, 01:26:45 PM »

1   Kato Sayaka
2   Endou Mai
3   Tonooka Erika
4   Koizumi Rumi
5   Itou Yuuna
5   Ookawa Ai
7   Yazawa Erika
8   Asahi Nao
9   Sakai Hitomi
10   Yokoyama Rurika
11   Tachibana Yurika
12   Miyake Hitomi
13   Kikuchi Ami
14   Fonchi
15   Etou Maria
16   Morita Suzuka
17   Hashimoto Kaede
18   Gotou Kaoru
19   Takiguchi Mira
20   Nomoto Manami
21   Kawamura Yui
22   Nagano Serina
23   Kurata Ruka
24   Ojima Chika
25   Michelle Miki
26   Kobayashi Maia

It seems like I am still fiercely loyal to 1st gen, at least at the very top:) By far the highest gainer from my previous ranking is Sakai. She has really grown on me a lot too!