Andy Roddick used to be really overrated. Back in 2005 and early 2006 after he lost wimbledon to Federer. The US media loved to over publicize him, especially for the US Open 2005. Then he lost first round. Recently, with picking up Jim Connors as a coach, he's been a whole lot better, and has developed his net game. However, compared to his 2003-4 era, the 2005 and early 2006 Roddick was definitely overrated.