JPHiP Forum

House of Seoul => Korean Shibal => Topic started by: daigong on March 17, 2010, 11:44:26 PM

Title: If you could swap members from a KPop Girl Group, who would it be and why!??!
Post by: daigong on March 17, 2010, 11:44:26 PM: Taking intergroup bonding to the next level (http://forum.jphip.com/index.php?topic=23917.0)...

If you could swap members from a KPop Girl Group, who would it be

(http://img7.imageshack.us/img7/6057/1z4k7tc.jpg)
(http://picroda.jphip.com/korean/jphip00785.jpg)

and why!??! :panic:
Title: Re: If you could swap members from a KPop Girl Group, who would it be and why!??!
Post by: lollipopgirl on March 18, 2010, 12:13:13 AM: So it was YOU who asked me that question XD
Title: Re: If you could swap members from a KPop Girl Group, who would it be and why!??!
Post by: miki on March 19, 2010, 04:40:25 AM: I'm gonna replace Seohyun SNSD with Sooyeon T-ARA.
Why? I just think she fits in SNSD like old times. I love Seohyun, great singer and now looking prettier, but sooyeon fits SNSD looks more. No?

And Boram T-ara with Sooyoung SNSD.. Height difference bugs me sometimes. LOL.
Title: Re: If you could swap members from a KPop Girl Group, who would it be and why!??!
Post by: lollipopgirl on March 19, 2010, 04:53:06 AM: My answer from when dai asked me as his test dummy XD

WOW! Good question! I'd make a super singing group with Taeyeon, Ye Eun, Sunye and SungHee <3
And then a super group with Hyo, Yuri & Hyuna for dancing skills, Yoobin & CL for the raps, Jessica, Sunny, Tiffany and Sun Mi for the voices... think that might be it... So many options! No Nicole coz I wouldn't want to separate current KARA <3

Technically I didn't swap anyone, I just made my own groups LOL :lol:
I'll do an actual swap soon.
Title: Re: If you could swap members from a KPop Girl Group, who would it be and why!??!
Post by: kuno_thunder on March 19, 2010, 05:44:14 AM: I like pops' answer of a vocal group, Taeyeon, Sunghee, Haeri (from DaVichi), and Park Bom? I actually think CSJH is the best female group vocally as far as actual harmonizing goes, but I couldn't split any of them up, lol. Of course since they've all got such great range vocally, it'd be hard to ask any one of them to just harmonize for the others. However once you're on the Olympic team, you gotta take on different roles that may be different than the roles you have on your club team.
Title: Re: If you could swap members from a KPop Girl Group, who would it be and why!??!
Post by: DO Me DO Me on March 19, 2010, 11:10:49 AM: Let's see, how about swapping Wonder Girls' Yubin for T-ara's Hyomin? I heard a rumor that Hyomin was a JYP trainee (under her real name) and was considered being the replacement rapper when Hyunah left the group. That would've been interesting, Hyomin would definitely rock those dreamgirls dresses.

Or if you're talking about forming groups how about G7 from Invincible Youth? They should totally sing a song together, come up with their own theme song or something. :twothumbs
Title: Re: If you could swap members from a KPop Girl Group, who would it be and why!??!
Post by: zoolander on March 19, 2010, 11:19:29 PM: A shortie group with Sunny, Taeyeon, Seungyeon, Sunye, Luna, Boram and Shinyoung would be epic.
Title: Re: If you could swap members from a KPop Girl Group, who would it be and why!??!
Post by: lollipopgirl on March 20, 2010, 05:51:55 AM: Quote from: DO Me DO Me on March 19, 2010, 11:10:49 AM
Or if you're talking about forming groups how about G7 from Invincible Youth? They should totally sing a song together, come up with their own theme song or something. :twothumbs
Hellz yeah they should! I am really surprised they haven't done that yet, thought they would want the moneys~ OH! They could donate the money they make from it to the village :D :heart:

*contacts Invincible Youth producers*
Title: Re: If you could swap members from a KPop Girl Group, who would it be and why!??!
Post by: lollipopgirl on August 19, 2011, 08:09:00 PM: Over a year people?! Wow, why don't Kpop fans wanna have fun with things like this? :P

So I have a new group that I want! Again, its not really swapping members but more so building an epic rocker group 8D
Taeyeon owned with that rocker intro to RDR and she seemed to looooove let her rock hair shake all about like that (delicious to watch too :lick: ) and my Yoobin likes to kick over mic stands and hang of stage equipment when she's getting her rocker on, she seems to enjoy it more than any other time she's on stage. SOOOO from that came the idea in my head that I want Taeng & Yoobin to run away together, seeing they are close anyway, and start a rock band. Today, I discovered how effing incredible E-Young is therefore....

I want an epic rock band consisting of Taeyeon, Yoobin, E-Young and Younha! Oh imagine the awesomeness *dies*

Who do I need to sleep with to make this happen?
Title: Re: If you could swap members from a KPop Girl Group, who would it be and why!??!
Post by: lucian2kr on September 01, 2011, 01:29:16 PM: I'd swap Miryo from Brown Eyed Girls with any member from SNSD, because there isn't any good rapper in SNSD. But I'm not sure which SNSD member would fit in nicely in BEG.
Title: Re: If you could swap members from a KPop Girl Group, who would it be and why!??!
Post by: zoolander on September 02, 2011, 05:29:30 AM: SNSD has plenty of members that are capable and trained for hip hop, they just don't really have a need for it. :lol: [noembed]Sooyoung's got freestyle skillz (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5zqJj0EPOjY)[/noembed]. ;) Hyoyeon and Yuri handled the rap verses in Tell Me and My Lips Warm Like Coffee along with Yoona. Sunny did a spot on 4minute imitation for on 1000 songs challenge. [noembed]Tiffany seems to be the unofficial rapper (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IODgDk7vYw0)[/noembed], she's always been the hype man and a gigantic fan of M-Flo and the like. Taeyeon is probably second to Tiff in the impromptu crowd working and had training from Jae Won and The One Himself, although she's never really shown it. :P I'm sure she could own it if need be because she has a great feel for all genres. I usually like her flair best in the quasi rap stuff like Visual Dreams and RDR.

I like pop's idea of a rock collabo, especially if it involves Taeyeon [noembed]channeling Maynard. (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tCp6f8JfYgM&t=1m40s)[/noembed] :bow:
Title: Re: If you could swap members from a KPop Girl Group, who would it be and why!??!
Post by: Rayle on September 09, 2011, 05:11:58 AM: Swap out Suzy for Hyoyeon. :grin:

:cow: Little Winners ft. the JYP Sisters! :cow:

Winners Girls - Korean Hip Hop Dance Team (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uyjkwOj5iw4#)

People used to say that the girl in pink is Hyo. That Boogie That Be choreo is certainly familiar. :lol:

Or just straight up Little Winners reunion unit. Make it happen, JYP and SM. You have that Global Kpop Conglomerate company now, no excuses!
Title: Re: If you could swap members from a KPop Girl Group, who would it be and why!??!
Post by: jerv07 on May 05, 2012, 10:43:24 AM: I would definitely put Chanmi of 5dolls in Girl's Day, because i think girl's day really needs another member who can do power vocals. Also Davichi's MinKyung in Rainbow so that all the boobie load is off Jaekyung and Hyunyoung has help with the vocals :D IU should definitely belong to afterschool cuz Lizzy isnt doing a very good job being maknae and thats all the changes i would make!
Title: Re: If you could swap members from a KPop Girl Group, who would it be and why!??!
Post by: bubbleguMs on June 09, 2012, 07:53:29 AM: Can I remove those two new members in T-ara and get myself inside? LOL JUST JOKING!!

Erm. Actually I love all the groups as they are. You have no idea how group dynamics change just because of an addition or replacement of a new member. I think most groups are actually doing a good job, so I wouldn't want to replace any one of their members.
Title: Re: If you could swap members from a KPop Girl Group, who would it be and why!??!
Post by: aerokinesis on June 13, 2012, 11:08:07 PM: Quote from: lucian2kr on September 01, 2011, 01:29:16 PM
I'd swap Miryo from Brown Eyed Girls with any member from SNSD, because there isn't any good rapper in SNSD. But I'm not sure which SNSD member would fit in nicely in BEG.

I don't think Miryo would fit much in SNSD. I mean she's a whooping 7 years older than Taeyeon. I also can't see her singing these cutesy songs, at all. SNSD doesn't need a rapper, none of their songs have rap and will probably sound weird if it did.
Title: Re: If you could swap members from a KPop Girl Group, who would it be and why!??!
Post by: lugasfandi on July 03, 2012, 09:13:47 AM: son ga in to SNSD... and Hyoyeon to BEG... i'm not sure why... but i think it will be fun... hehehe
Title: Re: If you could swap members from a KPop Girl Group, who would it be and why!??!
Post by: Lime on July 08, 2012, 06:46:47 AM: This swap would only benefit myself... But! I would Swap Kim Da Rae from Rania with Sooyoung. Only because I would like to see more of Kim Da Rae. :)
Title: Re: If you could swap members from a KPop Girl Group, who would it be and why!??!
Post by: Saiber on November 07, 2012, 05:44:42 PM: I would swap Dara from 2ne1 to GG. She seems more of the SNSD type... I think she feels awkward in 2ne1 imho.
Title: Re: If you could swap members from a KPop Girl Group, who would it be and why!??!
Post by: thatguylester on November 14, 2012, 08:14:18 PM: I would add Ailee to 2NE1 because she can sing and rap good. And she really sounds good singing R&B music
Title: Re: If you could swap members from a KPop Girl Group, who would it be and why!??!
Post by: Shenjin on December 02, 2012, 12:15:52 PM: Sun Mi to SNSD :x. she suits there the best imo. and she can continue her obsession on taeyeon :deco:
Title: Re: If you could swap members from a KPop Girl Group, who would it be and why!??!
Post by: ReDDsHaD0w on March 25, 2013, 07:37:48 AM: Honestly, I'd just swap everybody until all my bias were in one single group. :lol:
Although, IU isn't in a girl group, I'd like to swap her into a group with Jiyeon just cause I love them together after watching Heroes :)