JPHiP Forum
The PIEHOLE => H!P Crapola => Topic started by: shirenuファクトリー on December 20, 2010, 03:25:25 PM
-
Welcome to the Ultimate Morning Musume single poll! :peace:
This poll was last held here in 2006, which means it's not one of those annoying polls that shirenu runs every year.
This is the third and final round.
The voting for this round ends Monday December 27.
How to vote:
I actually had to think about this. I don't think choosing 3 out of the 9 singles would work. I also don't think ranking them would work.
So we'll go back to the good old point distribution style for this round:
You have 100 points. Distribute them among the singles any way you like. This means that, for example, you can give points to just one single by giving it the whole 100. Or vote all by giving 20 points to one and 10 to eight singles. The options are endless... Just CHECK THAT YOU COUNTED CORRECTLY UP TO 100! :lol:
shirenu's request: NO DECIMALS. I WON'T COUNT THEM. I TOOK SHORT MATHS AT SCHOOL.
I PRESENT TO YOU THE FINAL NINE:
Roman My Dear Boy
c/w - Fine Emotion
【HQ PV】「Roman～MY DEAR BOY～」22nd SINGLE- MORNING MUSUME。 (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-glx8gZNzB0#)
The Manpower!!!
c/w - Love & Peace! Hero ga Yattekita.
【HQ PV】「THE MAN POWER !! 」25th SINGLE- MORNING MUSUME。 (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZxSNqSDeZS8#)
Egao Yes Nude
c/w - Sayonara no Kawari ni
【HQ PV】「Egao YES NUDE」32nd SINGLE- MORNING MUSUME。 (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Klfyo-iFdd0#)
Renai Revolution 21
c/w - Inspiration!
【HQ PV】「Renai REVOLUTION 21」11th Single - MORNING MUSUME。 (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=c8y1OAUIxxY#)
I WISH
c/w - Akogare My Boy
【HQ PV】「I WISH」10th Single -MORNING MUSUME。 (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MqPBR5Sa43U#)
Shabondama
c/w - Namida niwa shitakunai
【HQ PV】「Shabon dama」 19th SINGLE- MORNING MUSUME。 (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=REbKeSK3N1c#)
Souda! We're Alive
c/w - Morning Coffee (2002 version)
【HQ PV】「Souda! We're ALIVE 」14th Single - MORNING MUSUME。 (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RxO9kWhc4vE#)
The Peace!
c/w - Dekkai uchuu ni ai ga aru
【HQ PV】「THE☆ PEACE！」12th Single - MORNING MUSUME。 (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-H_p0UnreVo#)
Do It! Now
c/w - Chotto ikashita Pure Boy
Ｄｏ ｉｔ！ Ｎｏｗ（モーニング娘。） (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M1R2RNJd4HY#ws)
-
40 The Manpower!!!
40 Do It! Now
20 Egao Yes Nude
-
What, no Kanashimi Twilight? Durr, well then.
25 - Roman My Dear Boy
25 - Souda! We're Alive
25 - The Peace!!!
25 - Shabondama
-
Oh if you're curious about some single missing, just ask. Stryfe was already asking after Kanashimi Twilight and it lost by 1 vote to I Wish. It was the tough round with sexy boy, kanashimi, shabondama, renai rev, i wish & as for one day... My lottery bowl is evil, I know.
-
Shabondama 30
I WISH 30
Do It! Now 20
The Peace 10
Roman My Dear Boy 10
-
Shabondama - 40
Do it! Now - 20
Egao Yes NUDE - 20
The Peace! - 10
Roman ~My Dear Boy~ - 10
-
50 - The PEACE!
25 - Roman MY DEAR BOY
25 - Renai Revolution 21
-
I WISH - 30 points
Renai REVOLUTION 21- 20 points
Do It! Now- 20 points
Souda! We're ALIVE! - 20 points
The * PEACE!- 10 points
Total: 100 points
-
60 Do It! Now
20 Roman ~My Dear Boy~
10 Shabondama
10 I WISH
-
I PRESENT TO YOU THE FINAL NINE:
Roman My Dear Boy - 30 POINTS
c/w - Fine Emotion
The Manpower!!! - 5 POINTS
c/w - Love & Peace! Hero ga Yattekita.
Egao Yes Nude - 2 POINTS
c/w - Sayonara no Kawari ni
Renai Revolution 21 - 10 POINTS
c/w - Inspiration!
I WISH - 5 POINTS
c/w - Akogare My Boy
Shabondama - 5 POINTS
c/w - Namida niwa shitakunai
Souda! We're Alive - 20 POINTS
c/w - Morning Coffee (2002 version)
The Peace! - 3 POINTS
c/w - Dekkai uchuu ni ai ga aru
Do It! Now - 20 POINTS
c/w - Chotto ikashita Pure Boy
FAIR ENOUGH FOR ME :grin:
ps: Kanashimi Twilight 150 points :peace:
-
Roman My Dear Boy-5
Egao Yes Nude-5
Renai Revolution 21-10
I WISH-5
Shabondama-20
The Peace!-5
Do It! Now-50
-
32 - Roman My Dear Boy
25- Do It! Now
23 - Shabondama
20 - The Peace
-
Shabondama - 45
Souda! We're alive - 30
The Peace! - 25
-
Renai Revolution 21 - 22
I Wish - 28
Roman my Dear Boy - 50
-
Renai Revolution 21 - 10
I WISH - 20
THE Peace - 30
Do It! Now - 40
-
No Mr. Moonlight? :cry:
01. Roman ~MY DEAR BOY~ - 50
02. Egao YES Nude - 50
-
:dunno:
Renai Revolution 21 - 50
Roman My Dear Boy - 10
The Manpower - 10
Shabondama - 10
Souda! We're Alive - 10
Do It! Now - 10
-
I WISH -- 50 points
Renai Revolution 21 -- 30 points
The Peace! -- 20 points
-
The Peace 30 Pts
Renai revolution 21 25 pts
Do It! Now 20 pts
I WISH 15pts
Shabondama 10 pts
-
I hate this :banghead: In a good hating way I mean XD
Roman ~My dear boy~ --> 20
Souda! We're alive--> 30
Do it! Now ---> 30
Shabondama ---> 10
I Wish --> 10
-
I WISH - 40
Shabondama - 20
Roman - 15
Egao YES Nude - 15
MANPOWAH - 10
-
shabondama - 70
shouda! we're alive - 30
-
I Wish -- 88pts
Do it! Now -- 8pts
The Peace -- 3pts
Renai Revolution 21 -- 1pt
-
^ lol I was gonna be like "THAT GOES OVER 100 POINTS MATE" but it was RR21 xD not 21 points x'D
-
Shabondama - 30
Egao Yes Nude - 20
Renai Revolution 21 - 20
Souda! We're Alive - 20
The Manpower!!! - 10
-
Renai Revolution 21 - 20
I WISH - 20
Souda! We're ALIVE - 20
The Peace! - 20
Do it! Now - 20
-
40 - Shabondama
20 - Ren'ai Revolution 21
20 - I Wish
10 - Souda! We're Alive
10 - ROMAN ~My Dear Boy~
-
:mon dunno: ok where's my calculator
let's see...
Shabondama - 30
I WISH - 20
Do It! Now - 10
The Manpower!!! - 10
Egao Yes Nude - 10
Souda! We're Alive - 10
The Peace! - 10
:mon exhaust:
-
The Peace! 80
Ren'ai Revolution 21 10
I WISH 10
:jphip:
-
Since Kanashimi twillight didn't make it... there's only one of my top favorites left!
Shabondama - 100
:yep:
-
Souda We're Alive- 50
Shabondama- 40
Egao YES Nude- 10
-
95 - Do it! Now
2 - The Manpower!
1 - Roman My Dear Boy
1 - I Wish
1 - Egao Yes Nude
-
Egao Yes Nude - 40
Do it! now - 30
Shabondama - 10
The Peace! - 10
The Manpower!!! - 5
Renai Revolution 21 - 5
-
My best 4 singles
The Manpower!!! - 40 POINTS
c/w - Love & Peace! Hero ga Yattekita.
Shabondama - 30 POINTS
c/w - Namida niwa shitakunai
Renai Revolution 21 - 10 POINTS
c/w - Inspiration!
Souda! We're Alive - 10 POINTS
c/w - Morning Coffee (2002 version)
-
The Peace - 50 points
Ren'ai Revolution 21 - 20 points
Shabondama - 10 points
I Wish - 10 points
ROMAN ~My Dear Boy~ - 10 points
-
The Peace! - 80
The Manpower!!! - 10
Renai Revolution 21 - 10
-
I'm having trouble deciding who to give what amount of points to... so I'm just going to pick a favourite and give them all my points! XD;
The PEACE - 100 points! :lol:
-
Souda! 30
Manpower!!! 25
Egao Yes Nude 20
The Peace 15
Roman 5
RR21 5
-
The Peace- 50 points
Renai Revolution- 50 points
-
Egao Yes Nude - 80
Renai Revolution 21 - 5
Roman ~My Dear Boy~ - 5
The Manpower!!! - 5
I WISH - 5
-
40 - Renai Revolution 21
30 - Roman My Dear Boy
20 - Do It! Now
10 - The Manpower!!!
-
Shabondama - 20
Roman ~My Dear Boy~ - 20
The Peace! - 40
Do it! Now - 20
-
For having the greatest combination of awesome A-side, b-side, PV, dance, costumes, and amazing levels of cuteness:
The Peace! - 100
-
Renai Revolution 21 - 20
The Peace! - 20
Souda! We're Alive - 20
Do It! Now - 20
Shabondama - 20
I would've given points to the three of the remaining four that I really like, but that would just complicate my point distribution. :P
-
The Peace - 40
Ren'ai Revolution - 30
Do it! Now - 20
Roman My Dear Boy - 10
-
RESULTS THEY ARE HERE RESULTS
Morning Musume - The Peace ザ☆ピ～ス！ (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=y8qKb_nDcdw#ws)
21 ザ☆ピ～ス!モ-ニング娘。 (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vbgK3duNA7Y#ws)
#1 The Peace!!! 853 pts.
#2 Shabondama 621 pts.
#3 Do It! Now 598 pts.
#4 Renai Revolution 21 458 pts.
#5 I WISH 417 pts.
#6 Roman ~My Dear Boy~ 393 pts.
#7 Souda! We're Alive 305 pts.
#8 Egao Yes! Nude 293 pts.
#9 The Manpower!!! 142 pts.
:cow: :cow: :cow: :cow:
DISCUSS!!!!
Opinions on the poll are ok as well.
If we do have this poll again in the future (after a few years lol) I think I'll add a "wild card" option that will prevent fuck ups like round 2 poll B lol
BRB KILLING ZOMBIES
-
No Complaints at all about this poll. Although "The Peace" came in 5th with just 10 points on my answer, I have to admit, it is one of the most creative music videos ever produced, and the background story makes it even more interesting.
My heart will always belong to "Love Machine", but this poll really proved an important point......Morning Musume has got a sizeable number of fascinating, well produced, thouroughly entertaing songs and PV's, and Tsunku san and all of the perfomers, supporting music and technical staff have earned a place in the Valhalla of pop music!!
A big thanks to Shirenu for running this poll, and for using the Shirenu SUPER COMPUTER to add up the results. Arigatou Gozaimashita!
-
YES now I have time to babble a little :lol:
A WARM THANKS TO EVERYONE WHO VOTED AT ANY TIME IN THE POLL! Some of the vote threads even reached page 3, oh happy tears of joy. Ya know the more people vote, the more epic the poll is :D
I personally had the most fun making the round 1 posts, watching all the videos and realizing how many of them are fucking awesome each in their own way :lol:
I even liked some songs more than I'd liked them before. Maybe I'm just in a different mindset lol
I hope at least some of you also took this opportunity to either re-live or to discover some singles, because... it's fun. lol
I do find it regrettable that Kanashimi Twilight didn't make the final round, and I know many others did too. So that's why I'd like to add some kind of wild card option next time, if there's only a one point difference etc. This also would've benefited Mr. Moonlight. My lottery bowl isn't exactly fair, so I don't think a wild card option would mess with the poll too much... :3
-
I hope at least some of you also took this opportunity to either re-live or to discover some singles, because... it's fun. lol
This really applies to me. I had fun and was hooked watching all the videos again, and seeing some of the newer ones for the first time.
The classics reminded me of why I loved that Momusu and made me nostalgic of that era~ :heart:
Voting in the different stages of the poll was difficult yet fun, and I am really happy that The Peace won~! :wriggly:
-
old school musume pwned the new stuff, not surprises there... ph but i got lots of fun watching the videos again, also i actually listened again some of the b-sides to refresh the memory
awesome work shirenu :heart: and sorry for making you count with two hands :sweatdrop:
-
I'm down with the nine finalists, although I suspect the randomizing in the earlier rounds skewered the 1998-1999 era, which was not represented at all in the final round -- BOO! on that.
OT: I've always been interested in where the line is drawn between old and new. Used to be Daite Hold On Me, Love Machine, Renai Revolution... Last I thought about this, I figured it was Shabondama, once and for all. Now THAT song seems ANCIENT.
-
WOW!! The Peace by a landslide?!! :lol:
i seriously didn't saw that one coming?.. ehehehe..
shouldn't Renai Revolution number 1? it has 21 458 votes?!.. XD (lame)
thanks for the fun poll.. :grin:
-
I'm just only wondering why Sakura Mankai wasn't featured here.
-
I'm just only wondering why Sakura Mankai wasn't featured here.
cuz it's by a splinter group, MM Sakuragumi
this poll was only for Morning Musume (full line-up) singles
==
i really enjoyed this poll and was actually looking forward to the next stage as soon as i voted in the current one
THE PEACE! at #1 is no suprise, this is still :hipheart:
i'm glad my faves made it to the top spots
watching all the videos made me miss those PVs that kinda had a story/theme to it and not just: faceshot, danceshot, dramaticfaceshot, randomgroup shot
hyokkori... had that crazy pirate thing going on and the roles (esp Yasuda's) was just hilarious
THE PEACE made us wonder about that toilet video thing
koko ni iruzee had crazy minecarts and conquering pyramids
shabondama had insane headbanging
go girl koi no victory had all the members telling us 'suki' XD
I WISH has the ultimate storyline PV award for me (cuz there was kinda a story going on throughout the PV)
i miss that
although i enjoy otoko to onna lullaby game and nanchatte renai solely because the music was interesting to me
thanks for making the poll shi <3
-
The Peace and the older singles was no surprise, however seemingly most if not all were within the 4th Generations run (2000-2007) which again was no shock but good job in making the poll work
-
Nine songs in this round and not one of them was titled "Love Machine."
Fascinating.
-
^ i blame Tsunku for that
-
^^ I'm actually kinda glad that Love Machine wasn't here, just because I feel that usually people think that they *have* to think of it as one of the best singles because it SOLD SO MUCH.... But when I actually think of personal favourite songs that I listen to over and over again, Love Machine isn't one of those D: It was a ~hit~ in Japan during its release yes, but it's not one of the songs I choose to listen to all the time...
And Love Machine actually won this poll the first time it was held. :P It wasn't run the same way though, and not many people voted.
-
Agreed. I kinda groan whenever someone punches it in at karaoke: the obligatory Musume song. I tell ya one time a co-worker sang "The Peace" and my drunk ass was a sight to see, doing the moves.
So not seeing "Love Machine" is actually a progressive thing in my mind. Still, kind of a bummer not to see ANY part of the 90s in the final round. Come on, TRUE fans still put "Furusato" in their top ten. Don't lie!
-
I expected the Peace to win. Obviously, on a forum that's created around Rika :lol:
However! I did some quick calculation yesterday and Shabondama had like a 150 pt lead on The Peace! Then all the last minute voters started giving tons of points to the peace and well, the results speak for themselves.
Hopefully Kanashimi twillight can make it past the preliminary rounds next time. It would be interesting to see how well it could do.
-
Interesting that Egao YES! NUDE was the only "new gen" song to make it into the final 9. It is not my favourite of the new-ish singles, even though it is really good.
I loved this poll, it was a blast going through all the PVs, rediscovering old songs I'd forgotten (I've been out of H!Pland for a while :nervous ), and catching up with all the new singles I missed while I was... occupied elsewhere :lol: I personally think a lot of the new singles are better musically than the old ones, but the old ones triumph because the PVs are amazing, and the line-ups epic and highly memorable. I tried not to let nostalgia and fangirling rule my vote, but it was difficult XD;
I wish SEXY BOY and Mr. Moonlight had made it into final top 10, but oh well. Maybe next time ;D!
-
Egao Yes Nude, Resonant Blue, and Nanchatte Renai fit into the category of, what I consider, some of the new-gen's strongest songs. Personally, I think Egao Yes Nude is on the bottom of that list with Resonant Blue at the top, but I guess that's the way the competition stacked up. It would be interesting to count some votes based on "current leader", ie. Yuko, Kaori, Yossi, Aichan. I guess "Osaka" could go either way.
-
so the peace won coming from behind?!.. XD
how about a poll on the best single of a shuffle/sub group?
or the best shuffle/sub group ever?.. lol.. i wouldn't know if that
has been done before as i am new here.. :lol: :grin:
-
^ I was going to do Berryz next because they have 24 singles and are visiting the US soon-ish :3
-
GOOD FUCKING JOB SHIRENU!!! :jphip:
FUCK YEAH THE PEACE WON!! :rockon:
We all went down memory lane and its good to help new and old fans relive the moments with threads like these in H!P Crapola so that they realize H!P Classic songs like "Minimoni Telephone! Rin Rin Rin" was actually sung by Mika Todd, Aibon, Nono, and Mari. Without the history, you never know where you going!!
So not seeing "Love Machine" is actually a progressive thing in my mind. Still, kind of a bummer not to see ANY part of the 90s in the final round. Come on, TRUE fans still put "Furusato" in their top ten. Don't lie!
Fo shizzle. Top 5 Even. Wouldn't a Hello! Project single Poll blow your mind? :lol:
-
What song was number one the last time this poll was done?