JPHiP Forum
The PIEHOLE => H!P Crapola => Topic started by: Masabi on March 12, 2007, 07:16:40 PM
-
"And for an article on a musical group, there are various other topics that need to be covered. For example, where is the discussion of Morning Musume's influence on other performers? On J-pop in general? Where is the discussion of critical reaction to the group? Where is the discussion about their songs, the themes in them, etc.? Their style? Perhaps the "Milestones" section could be converted into prose and combined into a "Sales and critical reaction" section discussing general successes and criticisms of the band."
from the peer review (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Peer_review/Morning_Musume)
If anyone has any information on any of the following, it would be really good:
- Influence on other performers
- Influence on jpop
- Critical reactions to them
- Discussion about their songs
- Themes in their songs
- Sales information
- A fair use image of the current Morning Musume, meaning one that was taken by a fan (non-promotional)
thanks in advance!
-
As for the fair-use image, I'm afraid that, even being a fan-taken one, it won't be useful for the wikipedia.
Japan's personal image rights are quite more strict than in other countries, meaning that you can't publish a picture of someone without express consent, regardless of where did you take the picture from. The only thing you can do to help it is asking the people involved or the company that manages their image rights to give consent for the publication of the images.
-
^ Then how does Friday get away with all that stuff??
-
Why don't you get a concert picture? I know a friend who went to the 10th anniversary concert and she said she took pictures, so maybe she took a picture of all the girls together. I can ask.
-
^ That's kind of what I was looking for. If you can get some pictures with all of them together I would be eternally grateful
-
I though the press was free to publish pictures of other people if it accompanied "news".
The only critical reation towards H!P that I can think is "kimowota" and "hentai" :lol:
As far as their influence on J-music, there rise in popularity a few years ago did lead to a little boom in the female j-idol/singer group. And that also led to the rise of "kimowota"
In terms of theme's of music they have straight forward melodic idol-pop about happy times, sunshine, and all that nice stuff, crazy funky pop songs about random girl stuff, and r&b-ish pop about relationships and breakups.
-
In terms of theme's of music they have straight forward melodic idol-pop about happy times, sunshine, and all that nice stuff, crazy funky pop songs about random girl stuff, and r&b-ish pop about relationships and breakups.
I just want to add "one-sided love" to this.
I'm too lazy to check but I'm pretty sure it's common in H!P songs as far as I can remember.
-
^ Unrequited love, I think it's pretty common too
-
Fair use is defined by where you are or in this case where the wikipedia servers are. If you want to put it up on the English wikipedia site you are fine. A country's laws only have jurisdiction within its borders and for good reason too. Imagine if you divorced your husband and xxxxx country's laws applied...
-
Why is this a concern at all? There is already a Wikipedia template in place for Hello! Project publicity photos...
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Image_copyright_tags/Fair_use#Publicity_photos (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Image_copyright_tags/Fair_use#Publicity_photos)
As for the structure of your Wikipedia articles, how much feedback do you really want? Or to put it more bluntly, how proprietary are you feeling?
-
^ As much as possible.
And I guess it's an issue because some people are iffy when it comes to wikipedia and fair use, and I was going to put it up at featured article candidate
-
^ Then how does Friday get away with all that stuff??
Friday gets sued for it all the time, they make enough money to outweigh the expenditures in settlements.
-
^ That's kind of what I was looking for. If you can get some pictures with all of them together I would be eternally grateful
Sorry for the late reply. Anyway, I'll talk and see what I can get, if she took anything.