*Th-thump, th-thump, th-thump*Oh, what is that?

Can you guess?
...
It's Bee falling in love with your fic, is what.
Okay, cheesiness aside, I just want to tell you that there is something GOOD GOING ON HERE LIKE OMFG. o________o I have to confess, I didn't really touch this thread until today when you updated with your latest chapter [EDIT: I started this comment 6 chapters ago. Your updating speed is Godly, my friend ^^;). I read the first chapter - and just couldn't stop. I ended up reading everything in one sitting (well I had to teach in between... but I couldn't help it and read whilst the kids were doing their work xD). I can't say I've ever been moved to do this with fanfiction (besides On Call xD). I'm glad I read all these chapters one after another, I think it made the experience all the more powerful. And when I finished the last chapter [edit: again, 5 chapters ago ^^;), I kind of felt like crying because there was no more to read. Okay so you get the drift:
I'm hooked.

WOW. This story's been with you since 4 years ago? Why has it taken you so long to post this? ;_______; (not that I would've been around to enjoy this 4 years ago xD).
It's pretty meaningful I guess?
ASFFDGTFTAKJDH!!!! Yes!
I'm kind of wary of writers who state stuff like that... and then you find they're overrating themselves and it's kind of like... >_____>. Lol. But I am
so agreeing with you on that.

You know what? This story really reminds me of
Orange Days in a way, one of my favourite J-dramas. It's a story that involves a deaf girl (who WILL not talk, only sign) finding love, and is positively
beautiful in its depiction of the romance that unravels between her and the main character. The feelings that show roused in me - I will never be able to describe it, and I was just reminded of those feelings whilst reading this fic... I love this.
I REALLY LOVE THIS. You are
good. This really is turning out to be an exquisite fanfic; beautiful, and meaningful, and my heart clenches when I think over everything that's happened so far and everything that has yet to happen. I'm afraid the heartache hasn't even begun. And I thought
my Ai was pitiful...

Anyway... I'll never cease to be amazed by writers whose first language isn't English, but who still manage to blow me away with their story and their storytelling, and you are definitely one of them.

It's partially inspired by a Cantonese song that I always listen to. (:
You must let me know what song you're talking about.
*Bee understands the power of music*I’ll try to go through this quickly otherwise I’ll be spending forever writing this comment while you keep piling on the chapters!

but yes, there is SO MUCH to comment on, but like I said, I’ll try to limit myself. Although I have a feeling I’ll be spilling out rivers and oceans of fangirling anyway ^^;
And now, I think I owe you this:
[
EDIT: please, while reading the following, keep in mind that I started writing this several chapters ago ^^; you've answered quite a few of my questions since then, so thank you.]
[Prologue] You revealed everything through dialogue here, yet it was so effective. I cried. I don't know why, maybe I'm just more sensitive than usual, or maybe it's because I've always been a crybaby, but this really did make me cry. I guess I can empathise with Ai in a way; I know the heartache of abandonment, I've been hurt by it before. I can't even begin to imagine what little Ai must've felt when she realised her parents were
gone. Really gone. Oh gawd.

It's too sad. And the new daughter - she just had to be one of our other musumes, and I wanted it to be Gaki-san. I'm SO HAPPY IT IS.

But... what kind of a heartless monster would you have to become to abandon your daughter, your own flesh and blood?

People who have priorities over their own family; that's something I will never understand. I will always resent Niigaki papa for that. Even her mother to an extent; she could've done
more. She seemed to love her child very much, but how could she also just passively accept her husband’s decision and abandon poor Ai like that? I would’ve done everything to return to the house and somehow make sure Ai was okay… find her a place to stay at least, anything. The hurt and despair that Ai's had to carry her whole life - did her father ever stop one moment to think about that? Maybe... we won't know until you reveal more of him. But I don't think I'd be able to forgive him. I seriously want to cry just thinking about Ai's predicament

Awesome hook for the story!
[Chapter 1] - Her past, Her present.I love the way you’ve incorporated all these little flashbacks (into most of the chapters, as I’ve pretty much read all the chapters up to 14 already) that help us to really see into Ai’s character, what she’s been through, and the constant haunting, the uncertainties that she battles with day and night… excellent job with that!

And well yes. Every time I read these nightmares that she has…
*Bee cries inside*. She can’t sleep past 3.16 in the morning?!!? Hope she goes to bed early then =____= ‘coz how badly would that suck; it would really throw her off her game. At least, if I were Ai, it would definitely throw me off my game xD I’m sure Ai has worked her routines/schedules around the fact that she has to get up that early, but again. It’s gotta suck :/
" Pa . . .pa . . .Ma . . . ma. . ." She forced her voice out of mouth.
So she has spoken before! These are probably the only words she’s ever uttered? And at such a time too… you have to wonder then, what exactly is Ai-chan suffering from? Just a social disorder she had straight from birth?
And really, if her parents were going to be THAT BARBARIC, couldn’t they at least make sure their Ai-chan would be okay?

Make some arrangements for her? She can’t speak, and knowing that she’s quite a timid child, I kind of feel that they’d left her for dead. EVIL, EVILLL PARENTS!!!!!

OH! Your Ai-chan is meeting up with a psychologist too (so is mine xD). Lol. They could be friends!

GakiKame <333 I can’t remember how many times I’ve read these two being best friends, but seems they’re a common pick for H!P authors. Of course I’m not complaining. These two are a really good combination; they have so much potential for hilarity and the occasional sweetness.

Cute introduction of them to your story, with Eri being hounded by an escapee aspiring-to-be-a-singer Gaki-san. Awwwww.
*Bee rubs hands together*. And the plot thickens right there. Of course, now we know a little somebody is going to HAVE TO bump into a little somebody else… xD
[Chapter 2] - The second meetingSayu! We haven’t heard much about Sayu in the rest of the story so far, but I wonder if she has more of a significant role to play here than just a passing friend (and Gaki’s past crush).
And yes, looking for a job and being able to maintain one when you’re mute must be terribly tricky; just another obstacle in life Ai must face.
*Bee pats Ai-chan* poor dear.
Eri thought as she stepped into the elevator of the building where the clinic she is going to work in was located. 'I wonder how will my work load be like . . . It's so exciting! Being able to put what I have learnt in college in work, helping the life of others.'
O___________O

And of course, it hit me. ERI IS AI’S NEW PSYCHOLOGIST!!!!! And cue lots of inner squealing and OH MY GAHs. And this made me think and speculate right away; apart from the role of being Ai’s new mentor, what’s going to happen beyond this? Is Eri going to fall for Ai too? Be jealous of Ai for stealing Gaki-san? Although having read a lot since, I can assume that Eri’s just going to be that lovable best friend who never interferes and is just there for morale support and good looks. And I’m not complaining about this either xD ‘Coz she could’ve easily been a character that caused a lot more drama than necessary.

Fujimoto and Nakazawa <3 Glad you have a few more of them thrown in there for good measure. Just using them by name is good enough to fill the void of where-are-the-OGs-in-fanfiction in me. Hehe.

"Stupid Eri…”
First, it was ‘stupid Risa’ from Eri, and now the thought’s been returned

Made me laugh. These two!

I have to wonder what Eri drew on Risa’s face though. If it was anything as funny as what Risa’s (real) parents used to do to her face…

"I'm gonna get her to pay for this by paying me a good lunch today."
For Gakikame, it’s all about food! LOL. ‘You better buy me a big meal’ etc.etc., this kind of interaction between them has occurred a number of times throughout this fic already. Funny. But yeah, Eri is such a good friend in this fic, always looking out for Risa.
FIRST TAKAGAKI ENCOUNTER!
And such a FREAKING cute one too! Randomly kissing random strangers (who of course are destined to be). Lol. I was shocked.

Realising that Ume was getting closer and closer to them, Risa pulled Ai's neck closer to her and place her lip on hers, trying hard to hide her face and not being too suspicious by just hiding under Ai's physique.
Awesome! This was such a sweet way to meet and get to know each other, lol. And possibly Ai’s first kiss??? I have to say I found plenty of moments throughout the fic where I was kind of surprised by the unfolding events. Though I shouldn’t really have been, having seen my fair share of Asian dramas and whatnot. Well yessss, this was definitely one of the moments! I was grinning from ear-to-ear reading this scene! And Gaki-san scolding herself afterwards for being so forward, is love!

And then, we have AiEri first encounter. I was surprised at how confident and sociable Ai was, actually. Makes me think how multi-layered a character she must be. <3 The ensuing mind game between the two was also very amusing to read. I really do enjoy the character interaction and dialogue you have in your story, it’s always so refreshing!

"You are a person, not an item. I would like to know more of your through communications rather than written information. And in order to write new assessment, I need to know you more personally." Eri explained.
^ and stuffs like that seem kind of unlikely to come out of Kamei Eri, but this makes her so, so attractive. Really wise words.
[Chapter 3] - The price to payOH! Eri is such a sweetheart. To take sign language classes so she can understand her own patient… of course, dragging Risa along might mean the bean can slowly learn to understand Ai as well. Killing two birds with one stone.
"You know what, Risa? You should really shut up before I decide to call Ume-san here to drag you back to Kyoto.
GakiKame arguments are the best. <3

So her parents have given in and decided to give Risa a bit of a gap year… yay? xD Of course, a year is plenty of time for TakaGaki to get together and blossom and all that. And when Risa has to return, what will happen then? >_____> I’ll have to speculate more about this towards the end of the comment…
Ai opened her mouth, but no voice came out. Sadness immediately dawned over the lady's face. Ai noticed it and brought the same sadness to herself.
And these memories bring that same sadness to Bee.
And then to have Ai-chan questioning the purpose of her life – what she is living for – that hurts to read. I hope she realises there is plenty of things to live for soon enough, especially when Gaki-san becomes somebody important to her.

More AiEri with the lunch meeting and all <3 It’s so funny and cute how Gaki-san drops by so casually like that, causing Ai-chan to want to get up and leave

and then Konkon appearance as Ai’s best friend, as expected. This was a great moment amongst all of them, so enjoyable, that little moment where Konkon and Eri tease Ai by stating the contrary to what she signed. Awwww. Ai’s panic is so cute!

Gaki-san following Ai to the washroom…
This scene is also one of my favourite TakaGaki moments.

I kind of felt some nerves reading this, as if I were one of the characters right there ^^;
‘Risa-san . . . At least you have a family. . .’ Ai looked away from Risa to prevent herself from tearing. {At least they cared for your being. For that you will know that they will always be there for you, no matter what happens.} Ai typed with the intention to cheer Risa up.
This was a bit of a heart clenching moment. What would Ai say if she knew Risa was that daughter they replaced her with? Wait, she can’t talk yet xD but you know what I mean… ;_________; So ironic that Risa’s the one running away from her family, whilst that same family ran away from Ai… and now, Risa wants to become friends with this girl. So ironic.

Okay… you’re going to have to excuse Bee for her laziness now, but I realise this is never going to get done if I continue to comment chapter by chapter >____< I’ll just use bullet points to get through the rest of the chapters.

- TakaGaki exchanging text messages. I find it adorable how proactive our bean is being in pursuing this friendship. I wonder what makes her so attracted to Ai? But who am I kidding, that question shouldn’t even need to be asked.

We all know why Ai is so attractive.

- Risa stealing Eri’s sign language book. Eri discovering the sign language book upon taking the pillow to hit her over the head. O M G. Epically adorable scene. I fangirl squealed a lot here. Thank you for writing this so wonderfully.

Can I also edit something? xD
{Sorry for the late reply, I was taking my shower just now.
I'm going to do some volunteer work tomorrow. If you don't mind, you can join me. - Ai}
- Awwww, Ai is already getting to warm up to Risa so easily already. Also, little moments like this:
“'Why do I feel like you are always trying to hide your smile?' Risa thought as she observed Ai's action”, and Risa staring at Ai on the train --- have my heart brimming.
- And as always, Ai is overly self-conscious about the silence between them, wondering if it was boring for Risa to hang out with her – of course. I really enjoyed reading about this kind of thing, there’s such a ring of truth. Especially having seen how noisy/rowdy Risa is around Eri, it must make Ai nervous that Risa’s unusually quiet around her.

- So Ai took Risa back to her orphanage. Nacci <3 She must be really old here? Lol. More revealed about Ai-chan here. And I LOVED the little moments of TakaGaki, like Risa realising she was staring too much, and thinking how beautiful Ai’s smile was... slowly, but surely, the bean is falling for Ai.

And of course, when Risa apologises, and explains why she was apologising. That was so beautiful! This was definitely a chapter that made me feel you were right when you said this story was meaningful.

And of course, Eri disturbing that beautiful peace with her call. Lol. And finding out about the Niigakis not approving of any of Risa’s friends – what the heck?!?! Eri really must be that amazing, huh? My respect for her has gone up even more, if possible. Must be that turtle stubbornness.

- Oooooo, celebration at Eri’s. So THAT’S the real reason for Eri having to cook? A bet on whether Gaki-san could pass the sign language exam or not. Major rofl!

Risa would be much too embarrassed to give Ai that reason to come celebrate too… d’awwww. I swear to gawd, I’ve melted reading this story too many times to count. >____>
Eri shot her eyes big in realisation. Her fringe was tied up in a childish way, with tinge of flour sticking on them.
GYAAAAAH!!!!!!!! This has got to be the single most adorable moment in the story so far! I can’t possibly describe in words how much this satisfied my fangirl heart!
Must demand a drawing from ropychan…

And then we have Ai-chan’s contrasting thoughts:
“…then you first voiced out that you hate having these lessons. It almost felt like you took the language for me, though it was not. It was just a bet to win Eri-san.”
NOOOOOO no no nonononononoonononononononoonononoooooo….. >___>
- Next comes caiyunki’s favourite chapter. O__________________O
- Ai-chan’s hysterial fit was . . . . scary.

;___; but you described this chapter very well, I felt every bit of apprehension for Ai and was wondering what the heck was going on. Poor Gaki-san for not realising a watch could produce such a reaction from her, and for believing it her fault. Poor Ai-chan for her inability to control her reactions. Poor Eri for not knowing what to do for her patient. Poor people all over the place.

- The very girl in Ai’s dreams… to be Gaki-san right next to her when she wakes up. Oh man, I’m feeling more and more worried the longer I think about it. What will happen to TakaGaki when the truth is revealed? Can Ai-chan still love Gaki-san back, knowing SHE was the girl who replaced her? And it’s so sad too, when Ai wakes up only to continually apologise for ‘destroying’ Risa’s party. >____< this chapter was rather distressing… you can tell that things are only going to take a bad turn from here. I really braced myself at this point to continue reading.

- The next chapter – Risa’s inability to concentrate because of MIA Ai-chan, and her subsequent frustration. And Eri, being the bestest friend in the whole world, comforting her.

"I - missed you. I want to see you." Risa replied as she looked onto the ground, teeth continued chattering. Her heart winced a little as her brain had decided to go truthful the heart's feeling.
*Bee flops about for a while and then melts all over the table and laptop* GOSH. How can Ai-chan
not scoop Risa up into her arms and kiss her senseless?! Oh yeah. Stupid traumatising past and all that. =____=
- And just when I thought Risa would blurt out more cuteness, along the lines of the I-miss-you-must-see-you that she’d done only moments earlier – only to be shocked (along with Ai-chan) that she abruptly apologised and left. And then Ai-chan… Ai-chan’s thoughts… of course she would see Risa’s departure just then as a sign of abandonment. NOoooo. How can she think of herself as a loser? AI-CHAN WHY DO YOU BREAK MY HEART SO.

- Cue angst from all parties. Poor Ai-chan who has just felt betrayed once more. Poor Gakisan who is so conflicted, and only wants to help Ai-chan end her suffering.
*Bee tearily huggles all the suffering people*

- We also have Eri who is still around to say awesome things like:
The time they need to recover from their hurt, is way more than any of us can imagine. So may take a few days, some a few months or even decades. We can't rush on them, Risa. The more we pressed in, the more they push us out.
So wise.

And now even Eri is conflicted about all this, with her best friend being involved. Gyah. Very messy at this point……

- The reminiscing about what they talked about (Risa’s talk about the stars). That had me all warm and fuzzy!

Awwww, the dialogue you’ve incorporated into this story – there were so many instances that had me nodding furiously – yes yes yes! Ai… she is just too guarded. Of course, that’s understandable given her past, but I wonder what it’s going to take to get her to open up and to trust more blindly – sometimes, you just have to. Especially so if you’ve found the right person to trust. It’s painful to read about Ai and how doubtful and wary she is of everything and everybody…

- Gaki-san is going to sing her OWN SONG FOR AI?
- If anybody can help this situation, it would be Eri… it’s always a friend who helps out, lol. Again, so lovely to see her making such effort to help Ai-chan. But our lovely is seeming to get more and more out of control now – her shaking, the seizures and the tranquilisers. O__O this is something to be extremely worried about!

- Awwwww! Kaorin, a sweetheart as always.

I loved that she treated Ai as in equal and saw in her good work ethics, and as such gave her more opportunities to work. Anything at this point to boost Ai’s confidence, really! <3 But of course, this means that Ai is probably going to have to face Risa. All to plan, author-san. xD
- Ai…
glared?. Ohnononono. Ai’s misinterpreting all of Risa’s good intentions, all those feelings. Every time you reveal her negative thoughts, I just want to grab Ai’s shoulders and shake her awake! This is really frustrating!

- AWWW! Look at how easily Ai gives in to Yuko! Respect trust, and all that.

- And then, another meeting between TakaGaki… this time, Risa actually getting down to business! @___________@
"What if - what if that day, I told you, I like you, what would you do?" Risa, mustering all of the courage that she needs, clutching the tickets tightly in her hands and asked.
(Don't say things that are not going to happen.) Ai signed. (I'm not here for you to fool around, please, Niigaki-san)
(Then I will not say it. If this the way you would want a conversation to continue, I will do it this way. If this the way of life you have, I will live it together with you in the same way.) Risa signed back to Ai.
My heart stopped.
You are good, caiyunki. Good good good.

This was such drama material, I loved it! My heart really swelled right here; this has GOT TO move Ai-chan, right? Ai is the type who won’t let Risa ruin her dreams because of her. Risa has reached the point of foolish love here, but it’s so… cute? How desperate she has become. “If she's not here, nothing else matters to me anymore” … stuff like that. OH MY SWEET TAKAGAKI.

YES! Ai turns up! And Risa sings her heart out for her love!

"I will say it again, if you are still doubting whether is it from the bottom of my heart, Ai-san." Risa broke the silence, seemingly to understand the uncertainty that was running in Ai's mind through the look in her eye. "I love you, Ai-san" Leaning forward towards Ai, Risa kissed Ai lightly on her cheeks and stayed there for awhile, until she tasted salty tears of Ai.
I think it’s about time Risa called her “Ai-chan”… xD You do allude to that a bit down the track though. But I was cheering with all my might, right here. Satisfying much?

- Wait, WHAT? They’re sleeping together already? And of course, it must’ve been Bee overeating and thinking too much. It was the sleeping kind of sleeping, not in the sex way (*cue On call hilarity* xD). And this was when the inner squealing would not stop. Kyaaaah! Gyaaaah! OH MY GAHHH! It’s finally happening for these two!

And when Risa had safely escorted Ai back to her apartment and was ready to leave for the hotel, Ai stopped her. Ai attached herself onto Risa, and that shocked Risa. "Is there anything wrong?"
(No.) Ai shook her head and signed as she pulled away from the hug she initiated.
"Did you want me to . . . stay with you tonight?" Risa guessed.
*Cue fangirl gibberish a-la-ropychan*

- Sleepy Risa is too cute!

And Ai trying to take it down in drawing, and the playful interchange between them as Risa tried to see what Ai was up to – d’awwww, I could really die reading this kind of sweetness.
(Yes. If silence is . . ) Before Risa could sign her answer, Ai stopped her.
(Don't do that. You have a nice voice. ) Ai stopped for a while, before continuing. (I like it.)
I read this like over and over again. Lol. It was just too pretty and beautiful in my head, I couldn’t help it!

Ai’s spontaneous little kiss for Gaki-san after receiving the flowers was also another adorable moment. This chapter was almost too good to be true. . . . . . >____>
Ai-chan opened her mouth and was ready to say thank you! OMGAAAHHH! O.O I was ready to smack Eri across the head, seriously… but then upon reading the next chapter, the whole world came crumbling down.
Gaki-san’s parents.
=___________=
Niigaki papa sure is one callous, very unlikeable man. How could he be so… UGH.

Horrible, horrible… Ai ran away, but now she knows, and she can’t bring herself to be with Risa anymore. All of this is just going wrong.. wrong wrong.

And now Ai’s headed off to hospital. There must be a heartfelt scene where Risa comes running to her side, right? Must be!
Okay, here was some more of my comment that I had started a lot earlier, but I didn’t want to erase it just because you’ve answered some of these:
Well now that Gaki-san’s in the spotlight after winning the competition, surely the media has gotten a hold of this. Word will most certainly reach to the Niigakis’ ears; though Risa now has a year to do whatever she wants, I wonder if her parents will try to make a move.
And of course, the fateful meeting between Ai and her parents – I doubt they will be able to recognise Ai, but will she recognise them? She has stated that she can no longer remember what they look like, but will seeing them again jog her memory? And will she be able to talk by the time she meets them? Because if so, they will not suspect her. And when they do find out this is the daughter they abandoned so many years ago… what will happen then? ZOMG THERE’S SO MUCH I WANT TO FIND OUT. It’s kinda driving me nuts.

I love the characters you've developed.

Although I feel that Eri and Gaki-san have kind of switched roles (I mean Gaki-san not being able to wake up early? Eri who can dish out expert advice, cook and take care of things A Okay? xD) here, but the change is endearing <3 And I love Ai here, how I love her... she has this quiet (obviously!) sweetness about her; it's so charming. Despite my love for sexy, confident, violent/hot-tempered Ai, I am probably more of a sucker for soft, gentle Ai-chan, and the one you've characterised in this story I feel is the essence of that.
The pacing of the story is great too - you've revealed to us things bit by bit. I thought that was very well done.

Now, we have a lot of background information on Ai, but Risa’s past has only been skimmed through, and I wonder if I’m the only one here who’s this anxious to know more about Gaki-san's past - how did she come to the Niigaki family in the first place? Who are/were her real parents? What happened exactly, such that Niigaki papa ended up with Risa as his daughter? Why can’t she remember anything about her past before coming to the Niigaki family? I have to assume that Risa believes the Niigakis are her real family… I AM SO CURIOUS ABOUT THIS. =_____= Hopefully, you will be revealing more about Risa’s history as the story continues; it isn’t fair that we only know about Ai’s!

Another wholly AWESOME thing I am looking forward to is for Ai-chan to speak again. What will be her first word/s in forever? xD (I have a few hunches). I’m getting all giddy just thinking about it! Gyaaaaaaahhh.

All in all, I absolutely adore what you've done with this so far; the plot, the characters, the interaction, the writing itself. You must be a clever one too – you do your research, or you’re just experienced in the topic matter (mutism and clinical notes, lol). It adds that much more credibility to the story. You've definitely found a reader in me, and I CANNOT wait to find out how this story is going to unravel from here.
Thank you so much for deciding to share this story with us, and I have every hope that you will see this to the end.

So now my comment will come to an end.

You’re probably breathing a sigh of relief, lol. But I felt it necessary to thank you… so I wrote a lot? xD Hope you enjoyed my fangirling. I wrote this up on Word document and the word count right now (minus your quotes) is about 4,400 words. You have no idea how much I struggle to write that much for uni, LOL. But I think this may be my longest comment in a post ever. Well-deserved.

Can’t wait to read the next chapter!
