Cast Age Community DetailsAbe 22 Amish From Punxsutawney, Pennsylvania.Jeremiah 32 Amish Adopted by Amish parents and grew up in Holmes County, Ohio.Kate 21 Amish Both daughter of a bishop, and an aspiring model from Lancaster, Pennsylvania.Rebecca 20 Amish From Punxsutawney, Pennsylvania.Sabrina 25 Mennonite Born to Puerto Rican and Italian parents, adopted by Mennonite family.