The movie absolutely deserves awards of the highest acclaim. There were expectations and reservations around Heath Ledger's casting, but he delivered an iconic performance. Best Supporting Actor is right because he wasn't in the film for the majority of it. Not so sure about Best Picture, not that I think it doesn't deserve it, far from it it's actually my favourite movie for some time, but I just feel that because it's based off a comic book, it will just be looked down upon by the panel, when it should really be judged upon the quality of the film. Something TDK has in spades right from the get-go.