Comparison/Review/Thoughts on PS3 (and my other consoles)...
I was recently convinced by boredom and some very impressive upcoming games to buy a PS3. So far I'm very impressed with it.
This thread is more or less my comments and random thoughts with some comparisons to my other consoles (Wii, PS2, PSP).
Physical Dimensions: First off, the physical thing itself. It's big. This is the smaller, slim version and it's still bigger than my original fat PS2 and dwarfs the Wii by about 8-1 in total volume. Currently it sits on top of the PS2 with the back 3 inches or so hanging off. This isn't really ideal, but it's too big to fit elsewhere. One minor annoyance is that the top of the unit is sloped so you can't store anything on top of it. I'm guess that this was done to allow heat dissipation, but it doesn't stop the PS3 from being a hog.
The PS3 connects to the TV with a standard HDMI cable – no need for a special HD cable as with the Wii. This earns it major bonus points. HDMI also gives it better sound and picture quality. (I have the Wii or PSP connected with Y/G/B cables and the PS2 with a standard AV cable.) Like the Wii, the PS3 uses a disc slot rather than a tray. It works.
The front of the console is pretty close to the PS2 – power on and eject buttons and a couple USB ports. No controller or memory card ports though – but they're not needed because of the hard drive and Bluetooth. Still, this means I can't transfer over saves from my PS1 games.
Unlike the PS2 and Wii, the PS3 doesn't have a vertical stand. Like I said, it's a space hog. It's the fat guy on the airplane who sprawls out over the armrests and fully reclines his seat.
Controllers: The PS3 controller is a wireless version of the PS2 controller with one extra “PS” button to access the X-Bar, a USB port for recharging and redesigned rear shoulder buttons. The rear buttons press in a bit more at an angle. It's a minor change and doesn't impair the operation at all. It's slightly lighter than the PS2 controller as well.
No complaints about that – it's the same design the PS1 used as well and it's familiar and works fine. The wireless aspect is very handy – it's only when I go back to play PS2 games that I realize how nice it is.
Aside from a a different shape (flat vs. prongs), the Wii Classic Controller has all the same buttons in the same positions as the Playstation. The main difference are that you can't press the analog sticks for games really needing a 16th and 17th button and the Wii Classic doesn't have force feedback.
The D-Pad on the PS3 controller is mediocre at best. Doing special moves in Street Fighter Alpha 2 (which doesn't support the sticks) is a trying experience. The Wii and PSP both perform better in that regard. Most PS3 games seem to realize this and use the D-Pad as four extra buttons rather than as a traditional D-Pad. It works fine for Castlevania: Symphony of the Night.
Tastes will differ, but I find the PS3 controller to the winner of the lot. Wireless is useful, it's lightweight and doesn't chew through batteries like the Wii Remote. It's also a lot more comfortable to hold for a long time than the Wii Classic.
The PS3 also apparently has a primitive form of motion detection. The only game I've found so far that uses this is Little Big Planet. The responsiveness and usefulness of the six-axis lags pretty far behind the Wiimote. You couldn't do Wii Sports or even No More Heroes on the PS3.
Remotes: The PS3 has a Bluetooth remote – the upshot of this is that it doesn't need line-of-sight like the PS2 remote did. It also runs on AA batteries instead of the more expensive AAA its predecessor required. The remote for the PS3 is laid out better than the PS2 remote. It adds a few colored buttons, which I'm guess are for BluRay stuff – but it loses the audio-CD programming buttons. Ultimately, I don't really care. The PS3 has MP3 playlists built into its software – so it's a much better music player regardless.
The remote is much bigger – it's roughly 30% longer and 300% taller than the PS3 remote. Surprisingly, it's also lighter. Unfortunately, you can't point it at the screen to move a cursor like with the Wii remote. This would have been handy for navigating menus and webpages.
Online Functionality: The PS3 wins this one hands down. The Wii's virtual console is pretty amazing – but the PS3 Store is at least as good. This is mostly because of the hard drive. It's pretty easy to download games and demos. The only negative is the install time and occasionally not being able to use the console while it's updating stuff.
The PS3 also has some nice media server technology. After about 5 minutes setting up Java PS3 Media Server on my PC, I can stream videos, music and photos to the PS3 in my living room. This is pretty amazing stuff – and it works well most of the time. HD videos do stutter a bit since my router isn't that fast – but it's also possible to copy the videos for smoother playback.
I really haven't used the PS3's web browser much – it seems fully functional, although navigation and zooming isn't as intuitive and with the Wii. The Life with Playstation apps aren't are easy to use or useful as the Wii's weather and News programs either.
I never got the online add-on for the PS2, so I can't comment on that.
Movies: DVD movie playback is fine – very high quality. I don't own any Blu-Rays yet, so I can't comment on those. Switching audio and subtitles on the remote was very fast and easy. Since connections only my TV are at a premium, it's nice to combine functionality. There's not a whole lot to say – the basics haven't changed since DVDs came out.
Legacy Emulation: I had a couple PS1 games I got for my PSP, and they work great on the PS3 too. Being able to play Symphony of the Night on both systems for a budget price is pretty amazing. Sadly current generation releases (e.g. echochrome) don't replicate this. The Wii emulates Gamecube games, but this feature is lost on me since I never owned a Gamecube.
Game Boxes: The game boxes are oddly sized – being somewhat shorter than DVD boxes with two cross-bars to prevent crushing. I'm not really sure why this is. They're shorter than PSP boxes – so there's not even consistency there. The boxes are also clear and kinda ugly. This is a pretty petty gripe – but I've been spoiled by the uniform white Wii cases on my shelf. PS3 games just look messy by comparison. Was the extra plastic to match up with Wii/PS2/DVD/everything else really that expensive? (Of course, since the size of the disc hasn't changed, they could just go back to jewel cases which stack nicely in CD towers and waste a lot less space. Little Timmy isn't going to pass up God of War III in favor of Warcraft II Battlechest just because the latter comes in a bigger box.)
Games: I haven't had a chance to play a lot yet – mostly a few demos, a game of NHL 2K9 and Saints' Row 2. (They were on sale for $8 and $20 respectively when I bough the system.)
They're very pretty, as expected. The controls are fairly intuitive and consistent across pretty much every 3rd person platformer I've played.
I'm getting Uncharted 1 because it's $5 with a second controller and Assassin's Creed 2 next.
I enjoyed the demo for LittleBigPlanet, though it seems like the sort of game that could rapidly become repetitive so I'm still on the fence about it.
I've got a decent list of games that interest me (Bioshock II, Uncharted 2, Bayonetta, Demon's Souls, Red Dead Redemption, Final Fantasy XIII, Tekken 6) and I'll probably get a couple cheaper games from the online store (Street Fighter II HD Remix, Final Fantasy VII, Braid).
That list is a little short on RPGs, so I'm open for suggestions for some good ones. I've already played Dragon Age, Fallout 3 and Oblivion on the PC. Some JRPG's in the tradition of Parasite Eve, Shadowhearts and Xenogears would be nice if anyone has recommendations.