to me, nate deserved it all the way even though he had too many tries on two of his dunks. but it still looked good once he did it. the fact he won because of his ability to elevate himself, especially the dunk over webb.
meanwhile, i thought AI's dunks were kinda repetitive at the end. 3 between legs. i always think guys his height dont tend to have nice form of dunks. this is why when a guy like nate dunks, it looks so much better than a 6-9 guy.
of course the judging was kinda biased towards the end.